Should Fansubbers be People?
This is a repost from Formula’s website with the approval of Merines himself.
We, in Ryugan, greatly approve what he said in that post, so we’re reposting it.
As anyone who’s read our blog long enough (or far back enough), I (Merines) am a person. I try not to come across as some high-and-mighty provider. I reply with words and emotions that are what I actually feel. I don’t intentionally “troll” anyone, though we’ve been accused of it in the distant past, mostly because of our infamously sporadic speed-of-release.
But increasingly in the past couple years, more and more fansubbers don’t portray themselves as people. They are characters, a secondary net personality put through a heavy interweb filter of sarcasm, passive aggressiveness and superiority that insists upon itself. Some easy-to-point-out groups would be Menclave and gg, back when it was in its “prime” (i.e. Geass S2~Bakemono). Release posts are often irrelevant or trying too hard to be funny. Viewers not using the recommended tools (i.e. MPC+CCCP) were cruelly taken advantage of by exploiting errors in other software. Groups would seemingly spend hours upon hours thinking of “new” and “funny” ways to annoy perfect strangers.
Who does this? Sure, one user might take credit for the original idea, and another might take credit for the implementation, but who really “trolls” fansub watchers? Characters, roles that these fansubbers choose to play online to fulfill something they lack outside of the internet. Sometimes not even that–sometimes as the group as a whole (see: Anonymous).
I once was an angrier fansubber, back when Formula worked on more popular shows (or just more shows
). People demanded more of us than we could provide, given that we’ve always been lenient on our translators when it came to real life timesinks. I remember when the first ordered chapters episode of Shugo Chara was upcoming and I would F5 /a/ and wait, not for the first feedback, but for the “shit to hit the fan.” And it did. Or when another group would randomly pick it up for a few episodes when we lagged a bit–especially when we would release right after them. I even saved one of those threads. I even posted anonymously trying to defend us. I was very angry because nothing is good enough for 4channers.
Then I realized I don’t have to care. We do good work. Not great, but better than most. Also I quit 4chan, so that helped a lot, heh. Is our group boring and drama free? Yes. Do lots of people line up to download our releases? No.
Formula is a group respected by our members, so go on their blog as well, they are nice as well. Formula’s blog
| Print article | This entry was posted by Badskater on October 18, 2011 at 2:52 AM, and is filed under News, Random. Follow any responses to this post through RSS 2.0. Both comments and pings are currently closed. |
Comments are closed.

about 4 months ago
Hear Hear!
*huggles Badskater, Vali and all staffs*
FUNsubbing all the way!
Damn I got loads of episodes to catch up to!
Cheers mates XD
about 4 months ago
<3 RumbLE
about 4 months ago
RumbLE!
Come back to us ;__;
Or at least visit the chan sometimes.
We miss you!
about 4 months ago
That’s all i can say as well. :>
about 4 months ago
*Glomps the Ryugan staff*
DOn`t worry too much, do what you feel is right to be done by you.
Don`t mind haters, flames or whiner..
We love you the way you are.
about 4 months ago
Urgh brings back memories of when I owned a fansite.
Some readers just did not understand I was doing it for free and was a hobby of mine and if I felt like changing the look I had every damn right to. It was not their site, they just chose to follow it.
So I can understand completely with fansubbers being the same~
about 4 months ago
We love you the way you are x2:P And respect, admire you work.
about 4 months ago
Shame that so many subbers and scanlators still get hassled so much by the “fans” to release…Thing is all of that takes time and between having a real life, things happening in the family and say school (for some of you) it can be a hard haul. Scanlating which is where I was, was very long winded at times (I did cleaning for several groups, one of which I had to edit out text and SFX and redraw stuff where say the big SFX was)
You have my respect. Thanks for Fairy Tail and I can’t wait to see what happens next D8! *sits on edge of seat*
about 3 months ago
Well written my friend respect to you
about 3 months ago
To be honest if you ask me, you do an awesome job, i would line up anytime for your releases, especially for Fairy Tail, and i know fansubbing takes a lot of time, so i understand it by patiently waiting for the next releases, anyway keep up the good work
about 3 months ago
I hope another release will out soon.